Root Canal or an Extraction: Which Is the Better Choice?

Tooth decay is a widespread issue that many people face. However, thanks to the advancements in modern dentistry, it’s easy to remedy the problem. Two popular methods are tooth extractions and root canal treatments. Because there’s more than one choice, it often confuses people on what choice they should make.

In this article, we’ll weigh the options between the two. Read on below to get started.

More about Tooth Extraction

Tooth extraction is usually the least complicated treatment for a cavity. It’s a procedure where a tooth is removed from the jaw bone, thus preventing the infection from spreading. The procedure is often done when you get a toothache, and the only way to avoid it is to remove the tooth.

That being said, there are a few things that you need to know about tooth extractions:

  • There’s a high chance of tooth loss if the decay is extensive.
  • It’s not always the best permanent solution.
  • Other methods can be used to treat the tooth.
  • There’s no guarantee of the tooth’s health after the removal.

More about Root Canal Treatment

A root canal is a treatment for a tooth that’s infected. During the procedure, the dentist will remove the infected tissue. They’ll then drill into the center of the tooth to clean the pulp. After that, the pulp will be replaced with a filling. It’s also worth noting that the tooth will be saved.

In most cases, the tooth will still function after the treatment. However, there are a few things to consider:

  • The tooth might decay after the treatment.
  • The tooth might decay even when you don’t have any cavities.

Additionally, root canal treatments are only effective on certain teeth. The more teeth that need to be treated, the more expensive it becomes. This means that only specific teeth can be saved through root canal treatments.

Why Choose Tooth Extraction

Tooth extraction is a good choice if you have a tooth that’s in extreme decay. It’s also good to avoid complications from an infected tooth. If a tooth is affected by a severe infection, tooth extraction is the best choice.

The good news about tooth extraction is that you can choose to save the tooth. With tooth extraction, you can avoid the complications that come with root canal treatments. On the other hand, the tooth is removed.

Why Choose Root Canal Treatment

Root canal treatment is ideal when you have a few teeth that need treatment. It’s also a good choice if the teeth aren’t too damaged. It can be used as a permanent solution and treatment as you live your life normally.

Cost of Treatment

The cost of a tooth extraction is usually lower than a root canal treatment. The process is focused on removing the problematic tooth. After that, you need to do follow-ups and checkups. Root canal treatments are more expensive because they require the replacement of the tooth with a filling, which is where most of your money is spent.

What Should You Choose?

There’s no correct answer to this question; it all depends on your needs. You should choose tooth extraction to save your teeth from infection. The procedure is also suitable if you want a quick treatment for teeth in severe decay. The good thing about tooth extraction is that it’s affordable.

On the other hand, root canal treatment is more versatile. You can use it to save your teeth and treat other infections in your mouth. It’s a great choice if you want to avoid the complications of tooth extraction.


It’s best to choose tooth extraction if you want to save the tooth. It’s also best to spare a few teeth from getting treatment. On the other hand, root canal treatments are suitable to keep a few teeth. It’s also good if you want to treat a few teeth at once. Regardless of your choice, the only thing that matters is your needs.

Smart Dental Care provides top-quality services for root canals in Holladay. We also offer other dental services such as extractions, cosmetic dentistry, and teeth whitening to help you put on the best smile possible. Contact us today for a consultation!